Furthermore, it is ridiculous to speculate the writers have any intention of exploring a autistic child storyline because if you were at all educated in this area you would know that this diagnosis did not exist in 1925, so there really is nothing to explore. There's a wonderful candid of them all playing the lap-fall game together on a couch. She is the third grandchild and second granddaughter of Robert and Cora Crawley, and therefore the third great-grandchild and second great-granddaughter of Violet Crawley and Martha Levinson. Thoughts on Dan playing the Beast? 3. Later that year, as the family is leaving for the grouse season at Brancaster Castle, Marigold and her cousins are brought outside to bid farewell. The little girl across the street & one of our nephews was "blank" like that when they were that age. She is the third grandchild and second granddaughter of Robert and Cora Crawley, and therefore the third great-grandchild and second great-granddaughter of Violet Crawley and Martha Levinson. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. I think Marigold probably shows a form of autism or mild mental retardation. What really surprises me is the degree of anger coming from some of the people writing in. What happens to Marigold on Downton Abbey? You never see that poor child smile. Maybe they just wore her out playing so she would stay quiet. Is she Autistic? When Rosamund and Violet learn Edith brought Marigold back, they insist on having her taken out of England again, possibly to a boarding school in France. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. Well, her behavior in season six, episode seven was so deplorable even I couldn't justify it. Does Edith also resemble her parents? This series has an historian that spends a considerable amount of time making sure everything is correct to the time period so it is difficult to believe that is is an oversight. Is Marigold Autistic? I'm watching episode 8 of season 5, and Marigold is sitting on Edith's lab. Marigold may have inherited some of her mother's traits. Tom confronts Mary over her malicious behaviour and her true feelings for Henry. She then considered giving her to a local farmer, Timothy Drewe, after she was born, so that she could be near her child without giving her away. While they are trying to suss that out, they've missed a key scene and some pithy Maggie Smith biting sarcasm. uni.pictures/DowntonAbbey. Read on for more from our 'Downton Abbey' recap! Mrs Hughes and Anna happen upon Marigold's picture in Edith's room when cleaning and exchange a look, implying that they have deduced that Edith has a child. Mary and Robert object to Edith's announcement at adopting Marigold, but Robert agrees after Cora insists they offer Marigold a home in the Downton nursery. The official home of Downton Abbey. Shes touched that the family is going to go. Youre just stupid and stuck-up to see it, she adds. He was the employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley, and the late father of her only daughter, Marigold. As a teacher who has worked with children with many types of disabilities, I, too, have noticed a disconnect with the actions of Marigold. I'm certain it will be proven later at the very least she has Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment. Throughout the production, all of the children seem unnaturally passive. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. 'Downton Abbey' Recap: Lady Mary Reveals Marigold's True Identity Lady Edith discovers that her engagement got even sweeter, as Bertie is the heir to his cousin's estate, but the miserable Lady. Autism? Thank you! Or, more likely, Edith and Rosamund may have spent a month or two in Switzerland after Marigold was born as Edith is already two months pregnant (having been told mid-June and trip announcement in August) when they announce that they would to leave to go abroad to Switzerland to improve their French. Her middle name is also unknown. She should say something before Mary does, thats all I know. I have a son who is 50 he was born with CP and other disabilities. Can't put my finger on it. But as a matter of fact, there is something about her. I think that the casting director chose the twins who play Marigold for their resemblance . I think anonymous user meant the twins. 3. [A servant opens the windows in the library. From iconic proposals to accusations of murder, here are the period drama's most memorable moments. ! 5. However, Violet and later Cora eventually learned the truth, along with most of the family, and Cora arranged for Marigold to live at Downton as Edith's "ward". Hollywood Life This is the official YouTube channel for D. Others speculate that the child playing the part may have been sedated to keep her quiet. Photograph of infant Marigold; sometime in late 1922 or early 1923. She's just a little girl, for heaven's sake! The series, set in the Yorkshire country estate of Downton Abbey, depicts the lives of the aristocratic Crawley family and their servants in the post-Edwardian Sayings Words Wise Words Downton Abbey Words Of Wisdom. Robert later notes Edith's obsession with the girl. The death of his heir aboard R.M.S. What is wrong with the child who plays Marigold in Downton Abbey? Finally watched the movies recently and I told my wife I Press J to jump to the feed. Lucy Maud Montgomery penned Magic for Marigold in 1929. "something off", what exactly does that mean? I don't care: I'd say something, or give the kid back to happy family who took her in. 4. I think one of the two twins is definitely "off" somehow. I just find the whole thing odd - either she is actually developmentally delayed/disabled, OR she simply appears that way on screen. Born Hopefully this should melt the miserable ice queens heart, for good. Marigold is then seen playing with her new step-grandmother, Mirada Pelham. There's bts clips of them playing with the actors where they seem more engaged and cheerful. Perhaps she is just bored with the whole process, by the time they get around to her part. Back at Downton, Cora learns from Mrs Drewe that she has a third grandchild. I've noticed it everytime she is on the show that she is sweet and loveable but definitely spaced out. Kennedys recent book outlines the huge increase in autism since vaccine onset just a few decades ago. I feel so sorry for her being passed from one person to the next, looking dazed and confused. Michael Gregson (b. Robert Crawley, 7th Earl of Grantham (played by Hugh Bonneville) (b. Downton Abbey on TV was much more lightweight, and this is a bit exposed in the cinema. Here are some to of the comments I found particularly judgemental and offensive: 1. She shows her a copy of Marigold's birth certificate (she had signed it with her real name instead of a false one as her aunt had wished, because she knew she might need proof of guardianship one day). Familiar faces from the past come back to haunt the current occupants, and once again Downton. DwntnAbby Fan wrote: I challenge your knowledge of "Aspergers", which was declassified as a condition over 2 years ago when the new Austism Spectrum Disorder guidelines were introduced and your comment is only from 4 days ago. She tricks him into telling her about Marigold. And I would like to thank all of you who chose to comment in a positive wa pointing out the stresses on production sets, the limited actual screen time for assessing anything, and if you take the time to check IMDB you will see there are several sets of twins that play Marigold as the pace of the story line is much faster than actual time, it would be impossible to have the same child over the seasons. Down syndrome children has definite physical characteristics which she doesn't have. Get over it, not all children are extroverts, maybe the girl who plays Marigold cares only to go home to play while her parents want her to undertake the role of actress. Besides, in series six we see her running around and playing. Finally I would like to say that I am surprised this forum was not completely removed from this site by the administrators for the condemnation of this child's physical attributes towards an unsubstantiated developmental disability is no different than if the comments had pertained to race or religion. The series, set in the fictional Yorkshire country estate of Downton Abbey. I think looking a little withdrawn might fit well with her character as a small child who is currently on her third set of carers in her short life. Cora reveals Marigold will have moved to her stepfather's estate of Brancaster Castle in Northumberland by the end of Edith and Bertie's honeymoon. My tears turned to laughter when Lady Edith finally meets the advice columnist, and its Sprat! Downton Abbey 2: Cast, Release Date and More. As one viewer notes on Reddit, Laila and Amelia Whitney played Marigold for the first couple of episodes in series five, but were switched to Eva and Karina Samms in the sixth episode. Also to know, Who is the father of marigold in Downton Abbey? This episode is all waterworks. Now, time for an update downstairs. I thought she was just shy !! I can't begin to guess what is "wrong" (or, different) about this child, but the producers of Downton knew they had a hit show and continued using this child actress. He then along with Edith, Robert and Cora drive to Yew Tree Farm where he catches his wife hugging Marigold. When Marigold was first born in Geneva, Switzerland, Edith planned to give her up for adoption with only Lady Rosamund Painswick knowing of her existence. She'd prefer to be back home with her siblings. It seems wildly unfair that the Drewes have to move, since all they've ever. I am on my 2nd re-watch of the series and find myself again strongly noticing how spaced out and withdrawn the little girls playing Marigold seem, especially in comparison to George and Sybbie. But Edith's aunt Rosamund Painswick decided it best to take her abroad to keep Edith's reputation safe. Gender It gives me no joy to agree with many there, but thr you have it. So secure does it appear that it seems as if the way it represents will last for another thousand years. Posted on: 1/12/16 7:40 AM ET. When the episode starts off, Edith talks to Lady Grantham and weighs the engagement. As Mary tells George to "come to Mommy" Edith almost says the same to Marigold, but cuts short and says "me" instead. Mrs. Patmore was so excited about her bed and breakfast, but when her guests are actually a cheating couple and not husband and wife, her place is tarnished with a reputation as a house of ill repute. Poor Mrs. Patmore. . Maybe she a bit introverted little girl that is disoriented on a chaotic shooting location. Edirh gently movied an ornate ornamen, moving itt slowly back and forth in front in Marigold's face Not once but twice, the little girl could not follow the ornament, but looked totally askance with a blank expression..Even a four month old can follow an object. This is a list of characters from Downton Abbey, a British period drama television series created by Julian Fellowes and co-produced by Carnival Films and Masterpiece for ITV and PBS, respectively. We hope you enjoy your stay. What really surprises me is the degree of anger coming from some of the people writing in. While they are trying to suss that out, they've missed a key scene and some pithy Maggie Smith biting sarcasm. Physicalinformation It's way too obvious and many people have noticed. I would find this contrary to the entire story of the Abbey which has been to embrace change and modernism. Cousin Isobel sees Lady Mary in the cemetery and tells her shes delighted she is ready to marry again. While she's always the first to tear Lady Edith down she took it a step further by breaking up her engagement -- and that wasn't even the biggest moment of the episode! Just because she acts different than Sybbie or George does not mean there's anything wrong with her. I have a son who is 50 he was born with CP and other disabilities. Other servants bustle about . I've been watching this show since it first aired and not heard a single claim of any sort of child abuse or mistreatment of the child actress who played Marigold. Edith had considered taking Marigold to America, dropping her title and inventing a dead husband. 4. However, Rosamund says - in Episode 5.05 - that she spent "10 months" of her life making sure the baby came safely. The television series Downton Abbey followed the lives of the Crawley family and the servants who worked for them at the turn of the 20th century in an Edwardian English country house. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challenged physical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. Liittynyt syyskuu 2010. As one viewer notes on Reddit, Laila and Amelia Whitney played Marigold for the first couple of episodes in series five, but were switched to Eva and Karina Samms in the sixth episode. I have looked at two videos side by side, and think there are two different child actors playing the part of Marigoldthe younger one in the earlier shows at the farmers home,had bangs and straight hair, and did speak occasionallythe one who was with Edith when she ran away, had no bangs and very tight curly hair, and no expression at all. Tours & tickets Oxford, Bampton & Highclere tour Film locations & Abbey tour Small group film locations & Abbey tour Half Day Highclere tour Downton Abbey tour dates - at a glance. Edith is not creepy crazy, she is trying to keep her child without causing a scandal for the family. Marigold (Eva Karina Samms) with her loving mother, Lady Edith. But when Edith receives confirmation that Michael has been long dead, she decides she cannot stay in Downton and be happy. As a teacher who has worked with children with many types of disabilities, I, too, have noticed a disconnect with the actions of Marigold. Kitty Colthurst 1 episode, 2014. He admits to Cora he agrees with her that she is a "dear little thing" but feels there is something about her, a "sense of deja vu" that he cannot quite understand. There was something that didn't look right. They'd look at you with that blank expression or like "who are you, why are you talking to me, go away" type thing. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Does anyone think that maybe the second girl has Down's Syndrome? The Christmas clip is most telling. As a mother of 2 children diagnosed with ASD I am very familiar with the condition and it didn't even cross my mind when watching the program. There is no possible way any of you are specialized to the point where you could diagnose a child with ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) based on 10 second video bites of a child acting. . However, this remains unconfirmed. Do you watch Downton Abbey more for the fashion than those dramatic plotlines? It was so noticeable to me that i sat up and paid attention if she seemed happy. Autistic children often look perfectly "right". Marigold (late December, 1922 or early January 1923) is the illegitimate daughter and only child of Edith Pelham and the late Michael Gregson. Here's a theory - perhaps the reason something is "off" is because she was in Switzerland as an infant, living with the Drewes as a toddler, and in the Abbey as a preschool aged child. However, I want to give her the benefit of the doubt. I'd never guess Mary had a kid, but Edith wears that mess. An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challengedphysical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. Of course, it's still possible that you'll see Oliver Barker as George Crawley in the film, and even Edith Pelham's daughter Marigold. Two/three-year-old Marigold with her adoptive mother, Margie Drewe. It's been said that the children tire quickly, and get bored, and so their "parents" play with them to keep up their interest. If so, you're in luck because the show's gorgeous. Marigold and Edith Because of the taciturnity and often blank expression of the little girl who plays Marigold Gregson on Downton Abbey, I wondered if the character was supposed to have developmental problems. Aspergers? To write spoilers in comments use the following format Downton Abbey movie reviews & Metacritic score: The Crawleys and their intrepid staff prepare for the most important moment of their lives. Once Mr. Moseley tells his students about his background in service, they seem to understand him more and listen to him. Several of events in the series have led me to beleive this, Most particular, last Christmas's edisode, when Edith was holding Marigold in her arms , while the familiy gathered around the tree. 9 likes. Or if she was cast to be especially unengaged with the others due to her early life? Is diversity non existent in your world? Marigold is then playing tag with her cousins near Sybil's grave while Edith happily watches her. It made sense to not give Marigold many lines because of how much was going on around her and getting used to different places to live. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Marigold was standing beside them, lookiing once again, uninvolved and distracted as the other children were doing puzzles Even Louis Bayard from the N.Y. Times wonders about her, asking, Isnt it time she starts to talk? I feel like all passionate DA fans would react like this. I think that being more shy and withdrawn fits very well with Marigold's character, the child had been moved around a lot in her first years of life. However much I love him, I will always love you, she says. Perhaps she doesn't like Edith? Edith is deeply moved, and later Tom reveals he knows the truth as well, saying where he grew up "there were quite a few Marigolds" - his cousin Nuala had had a daughter out of wedlock who was brought up as her sister, and though the family never talked about it, they all knew the truth. What Are The 3 Basic Elements Of Theatre, Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Edith ensures baby Marigold a life near Downton. I've heard of very young children being purposefully tired out so they're quieter and less fidgety on camera, so it could be that? Full episode guide for Downton Abbey Season 1 Episode 1 A telegram arrives and we learn the Titanic is sunk. She has two maternal aunts, Mary Talbot and the late Sybil Branson, and three maternal uncles, Tom Branson, the late Matthew Crawley, and Henry Talbot. The death of his heir aboard R.M.S. Downton Abbey season 6. Lady Mary comes down to breakfast in search of Henry, and when he wasnt there she looks defeated and then Bertie wants to share the news of the engagement. Just saw the last eposoide in which she has more screen time and it was obvious that this is not the behavior of a normal child. - Downton Abbey Wiki | Why did Cora take Marigold back to Downton Abbey? Michael Gregson (biological father) Edith Pelham (mother/legal guardian)Herbert Pelham (stepfather)Peter Pelham (half-brother) Instead, Downton leaves its audience dreaming of an aristocratic life - where they might be as beautiful as Cora, Countess of Grantham (Elizabeth Those of us who agree with her will savour every minute of Downton Abbey, even the flawed ones. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challenged physical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. Misery truly loves company and the depressed widow couldn't stand to see her sister happy. He was the employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley, and the late father of her only daughter, Marigold. Get over it, not all children are extroverts, maybe the girl who plays Marigold cares only to go home to play while her parents want her to undertake the role of actress. Pictures Of Sandwiches With Names, do fungi have cell walls made of cellulose. I noticed that the Samms girls seemed withdrawn, but that might have been their response to being on a set with so many people and so much going on all around them, rather than anything medical. I think they probably purposefully did her scenes close to the girls' nap time because Edith and The Drewes had a lot of really dramatic scenes with Marigold, so they'd really want the girls playing her to be as calm as possible for those moments. They grow up so quickly! Once the family hears the news of Barrows suicide attempt, Lady Mary pins it on her father for trying to fire him. I don't think there's anything wrong with her. This is a BABY being a BABYnot an actor. I wondered the same thing about Marigold, but then I remembered a comment Robert made to Cora after Edith became engaged ("She couldn't get her dolls to do what she wanted"), and they were hopeful she had finally found happiness. BAFTA Celebrates Downton Abbey - Page 11 at Issuu.com. If she was just "bored or tired" they should have picked a more animated child for the part. Is Marigold on Downton Abbey autistic? Mary calls for Henry, but before he arrives she pays a visit to Matthews grave. Oh, I dunno. Qualities Of A Career Woman, Autism? But after returning, Edith was troubled at having to give up her child. Lack of tracking with the eye, lack of eye contact, lack of emoting, lack of speech/delayed speech, lack of responding to inquiries and cues, etc. When Rosamund and Cora find Edith at work, Marigold is still at the hotel, where according to Edith they can arrange for a babysitter when necessary. Mrs. Drewe broke down. Welcome to the Downton Abbey subreddit, a place to discuss all things related to the show, the 2 feature films, the cast and the real-life history/context . I hate it when adults want to pinhold a child into being what they think a child should be. 1:06. Familiar faces from the past come back to haunt the current occupants, and once again Downton. But because she would like Marigold to grow up English and does not wish for the magazine business to crumble, she chose not to do that. But outside of the ITV series, it seems that they haven't acted in anything else, according to their IMDb pages. Thanks to Mr. Mason's encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence. Lady Ediths suitor begs for her hand in marriage, and she agrees before being able to spit out the truth about Marigold. It's hard to watch. Recently is possible to find a disease to describe everything making them a trend. It almost breaks up Edith & Bertie. We are there legally to ensure the child's health and safety and emotional needs are being met on set. To write spoilers in comments use the following format This is a list of characters from Downton Abbey, a British period drama television series created by Julian Fellowes and co-produced by Carnival Films and Masterpiece for ITV and PBS, respectively. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. ", Late December, 1922 or Early January 1923 (age 5-6). 24.60.28.139Agree! She was born in Geneva, Switzerland, and given up for adoption to Mr and Mrs Schroeder after her mother breastfed her. . why not bring up even Down Syndrome while we're at? Granny's Past and a Baby Bates? Marigold along with George watch Mrs Patmore prepare a cake, and they ask if they can lick the batter, later getting piggy back rides with Barrow. Marigold is the only member of her generation in the, Marigold is the second child on the show born out of wedlock whose father was killed; the first being. Where Are The Stars Who Played Marigold In Downton Abbey Now. Kids can be a vast range of characters and personalities. 9 likes. Lady Edith's imposter daughter, Marigold, becomes the first child spy for the Germans when she receives a series of invisible-ink telegrams from Berlin. The 10 Best Downton Abbey Episodes. I agree. Play Sound. Of the three Crawley grandchildren, Marigold spoke least in the series; as her cousins. She really is getting meaner by the moment. Weve watched Lady Mary manipulate situations and really tear down her sister, but it wasnt until this episode that she finally got what she deserved and it definitely wasnt easy to swallow. chill out, seriously. As to your likening of Aspergers to a "dreaful [sic] impediment" is very short sighted as many people diagnosed with the condition as children, with the help of caring and understanding therapies, grow into productive, intelligent and socially adjusted adults. Taking Marigold away from her mother caused not a peep,surely a first for children. . She goes up to Ediths room as shes crying and packing. Do they just pick children of the crew or something? She's had to settle for being an extremely talented movie director instead. I think it is shocking that her parents and the producers would continue to cast her when she is far more overwhelmed than any child actress I have ever seen. That doesn't sound dreadful to me. All of you who have made such judgemental comments above should be ashamed of yourselves. or is seriously traumatized to fein the kind of passivity that is NOT normal for a child of any age.. either which way, there is something askew about dear sweet, young, appearing to be traumatized, marigold whoever is directing, producing, financing this $netflix money maker should have and hopefully WILL make the hard decision to replace their marigold character to those of us who quite frankly see what you see, this is inexcusable .. get on it do what you should have done. You people are looking way too deeply into this. Recently is possible to find a disease to describe everything making them a trend. Meanwhile the pharmaceutical companies also benefit from total indemnification from injuring anyone with their products. It's Edith's daughter. Find all 17 songs in Downton Abbey Soundtrack, with scene descriptions. Things are about to get steamy at the Grantham country house in Downton Abbey. He captioned the post: "It's Grandpa time at Donk's crche . This show would have has at least 2 chaperones, probably 3 on set at any one time who would hit the roof if they felt either of these were true so I find these claims incredibly hard to buy and was wondering if anyone knew of a factual explanation? It gives me no joy to agree with many there, but thr you have it, Geesh, such ignorance! Is she Autistic? : , , . Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. MC. Before she was born, her mother had first considered having an abortion (because she feared becoming an outcast for having an illegitimate child, Michael having mysteriously vanished in Germany without a trace) but backed out at the last minute. Typical of the aristocratic life in the early 1900's, Marigold now lives under the stigma of adoption, while being cared for by nannies- yet another bond she will have to build. Conspiracy theory: Lord Grantham and Matthew, Press J to jump to the feed. I'm certain it will be proven later at the very least shehas Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment. Viewers will see the Earl of Grantham commit the ultimate betrayal as he shares a steamy kiss with his maid, Jane, on Sunday night. Mrs Drewe claims that Marigold was bored and that the Crawley family were not looking after her nor paying her any attention and she feels Marigold belongs with them. What? They seemed much more engaged and present in the movie and in pictures on the DA Insta, they seem totally normal. ASD does not have any specific physical malformations. Luckily, with a missing truck and wife, Mr. Drewe. What is wrong with the child who plays Marigold in Downton Abbey? Not really an actress. The dark ages are over and we don't hide behind closed curtains anymore, people. But where are the actresses now, and could they possibly appear in the second film? Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. It's clearly just a case of the actresses needing to get used to the set. You are the one who needs to beenlightened before you speak; after having done so I am certain we can all lighten up. It's wild and overwhelming and this is simply a baby or one of twins, who is tired, over-loaded, confused, trying to pick her own parent out of the crowd of strangers (yes, she's seen them before, but they are not part of her small world), lights, poles, cords, machinery, people constantly infereing etc. SPOILER ALERT: Downstairs comes upstairs as Downton's Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his new maid. 'Downton Abbey' Recap: Marigold Gets Kidnapped A kidnapping rocks Downton as Marigold goes missing and wedding drama brews as Mrs. Hughes and Mr. Carson can't agree on where to get married.. It's way too obvious and many people have noticed. Single Barrel Vs Double Barrel, When he realizes after the unveiling of the village war memorial that Marigold reminds him of Michael Gregson, he guesses the truth and confirms it with Cora. This I find a poor choice by the casting agent unless it was completely intentional and in keeping with Edith's ongoing unfortunate life circumstances. : , , . Ms. Baxter offers to go with him for moral support, and mentions that Barrow seemed out. Downton Abbey: The Exhibition. Carson and Mrs. Hughes take their shoes off and wade. please stop improvise yourself psychiatrists while watching a bored little girl.
Excel Weather Formula,
Where Did The Tornado Hit In Wisconsin?,
Madison Sunday Brunch,
S93 Speeding Washington State,
Articles M